Top UN court says Israel’s presence in occupied Palestinian territories is illegal

The apical U.N. tribunal said Friday that Israel’s beingness successful nan Palestinian occupied territories is “unlawful” and called connected it to extremity and for colony building to extremity immediately, issuing an unprecedented, sweeping condemnation of Israel’s norm complete nan lands it captured 57 years ago.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu quickly denounced nan nonbinding sentiment issued by nan 15-judge sheet of nan International Court of Justice, saying nan territories are portion of nan Jewish people’s historical “homeland.” But nan resounding breadth of nan determination could effect world sentiment and substance moves for unilateral nickname of a Palestinian state.

The judges pointed to a wide database of policies, including nan building and description of Israeli settlements successful nan West Bank and eastbound Jerusalem, usage of nan area’s earthy resources, nan annexation and imposition of imperishable power complete lands and discriminatory policies against Palestinians, each of which it said violated world law.

The tribunal said Israel had nary correct to sovereignty successful nan territories, was violating world laws against acquiring territory by unit and was impeding Palestinians’ correct to self-determination. It said different nations were obliged not to “render assistance aliases assistance successful maintaining” Israel’s beingness successful nan territories. It said Israel must extremity colony building instantly and that existing settlements must beryllium removed, according to a summary of nan much than 80-page sentiment publication retired by tribunal President Nawaf Salam.

Israel’s “abuse of its position arsenic nan occupying power” renders its “presence successful nan occupied Palestinian territory unlawful,” nan tribunal said, saying its beingness must beryllium ended arsenic “rapidly arsenic possible.”

The court’s opinion, sought by nan U.N. General Assembly aft a Palestinian request, came against nan backdrop of Israel’s devastating subject battle connected Gaza, which was triggered by nan Hamas-led attacks successful confederate Israel connected Oct. 7. In a abstracted case, nan International Court of Justice is considering a South African declare that Israel’s run successful Gaza amounts to genocide, a declare that Israel vehemently denies.

The tribunal said nan General Assembly and Security Council — wherever staunch Israeli state nan United States holds a veto — should see “the precise modalities” to extremity Israel’s beingness successful nan territories.

Israel, which usually considers nan United Nations and world tribunals arsenic unfair and biased, didn’t nonstop a ineligible squad to nan hearings. Instead, it submitted written comments, saying that nan questions put to nan tribunal are prejudiced and neglect to reside Israeli information concerns. Israeli officials person said nan court’s involution could undermine nan bid process, which has been stagnant for much than a decade.

“The Jewish group are not conquerors successful their ain onshore — not successful our eternal superior Jerusalem and not successful nan onshore of our ancestors successful Judea and Samaria,” Netanyahu said successful a connection issued by his office, utilizing nan biblical position for nan West Bank. “No mendacious determination successful The Hague will distort this humanities truth and likewise nan legality of Israeli colony successful each nan territories of our homeland cannot beryllium contested.”

Speaking extracurricular nan court, Riad Malki, an advisor to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, called nan sentiment “a watershed infinitesimal for Palestine, for justness and for world law.”

He said different nations must now “uphold nan clear obligations” outlined by nan court. “No actions of immoderate benignant … to support Israel’s forbidden occupation.”

Israel captured nan West Bank, eastbound Jerusalem and Gaza Strip successful nan 1967 Mideast war. The Palestinians activity each 3 areas for an independent state.

Israel considers nan West Bank to beryllium disputed territory, whose early should beryllium decided successful negotiations, while it has moved populations location successful settlements to solidify its hold. It has annexed eastbound Jerusalem successful a move that isn’t internationally recognized, while it withdrew from Gaza successful 2005 but maintained a blockade of nan territory aft Hamas took powerfulness successful 2007. The world organization mostly considers each 3 areas to beryllium occupied territory.

The court’s determination strikes astatine nan bosom of nan ambiguity of Israel’s management of nan territories. Israel hasn’t annexed nan West Bank — though settler groups person pressed it to do truthful — but it calls it portion of its homeland and has efficaciously treated it arsenic an hold of nan nation. Along pinch nan settlements, it has appropriated ample swaths of nan territory arsenic “state lands.” At nan aforesaid time, Netanyahu’s authorities has many times rejected nan creation of immoderate Palestinian state. Abbas’ Palestinian Authority has been restricted to power complete divided enclaves scattered astir nan West Bank.

Trending Now

The Palestinians presented arguments astatine hearings successful February, on pinch 49 different nations and 3 world organizations. In nan hearings, Malki accused Israel of apartheid and urged nan United Nations’ apical tribunal to state that Israel’s business of lands sought by nan Palestinians is forbidden and must extremity instantly and unconditionally for immoderate dream for a two-state early to survive.

Erwin van Veen, a elder investigation chap astatine nan Clingendael deliberation vessel successful The Hague, said earlier nan determination that a ruling that Israel’s policies breach world rule would “isolate Israel further internationally, astatine slightest from a ineligible constituent of view.”

He said specified a ruling would region “any benignant of legal, political, philosophical underpinning of nan Israeli description project.” It could besides summation nan number of countries that admit a Palestinian state, successful peculiar successful nan Western world, pursuing nan caller illustration of Spain and Norway and Ireland, he said.

It’s not nan first clip nan ICJ has been asked to springiness its ineligible sentiment connected Israeli policies. Two decades ago, nan tribunal ruled that Israel’s West Bank separation obstruction was “contrary to world law.” Israel boycotted those proceedings, saying they were politically motivated.

Israel says nan obstruction is simply a information measure. Palestinians opportunity nan building amounts to a monolithic onshore grab, because it often dips into nan West Bank.

Israel has built good complete 100 settlements, according to nan anti-settlement monitoring group Peace Now. The West Bank settler organization has grown by much than 15% successful nan past 5 years to much than 500,000 Israelis, according to a pro-settler group.

Israel besides has annexed eastbound Jerusalem and considers nan full metropolis to beryllium its capital. An further 200,000 Israelis unrecorded successful settlements built successful eastbound Jerusalem that Israel considers to beryllium neighborhoods of its capital. Palestinian residents of nan metropolis look systematic discrimination, making it difficult for them to build caller homes aliases grow existing ones.

The world organization considers each settlements to beryllium forbidden aliases obstacles to bid since they are built connected lands sought by nan Palestinians for their state.

Netanyahu’s hard-line authorities is dominated by settlers and their governmental supporters. Netanyahu has fixed his finance minister, Bezalel Smotrich, a erstwhile settler leader, unprecedented authority complete colony policy. Smotrich has utilized this position to cement Israel’s power complete nan West Bank by pushing guardant plans to build much colony homes and to legalize outposts.